| Year | Lg | Result | Location | MVP |
| 2008 | NBA | Sophomores 136, Rookies, 109 | New Orleans Arena, New Orleans, LA | Daniel Gibson |
| 2007 | NBA | Sophomores 155, Rookies, 114 | Thomas & Mack Center, Las Vegas, NV | David Lee |
| 2006 | NBA | Sophomores 106, Rookies, 96 | Toyota Center, Houston, TX | Andre Iguodala |
| 2005 | NBA | Sophomores 133, Rookies, 106 | Pepsi Center, Denver, CO | Carmelo Anthony |
| 2004 | NBA | Sophomores 142, Rookies, 118 | Staples Center, Los Angeles, CA | Amare Stoudemire |
| 2003 | NBA | Sophomores 132, Rookies, 112 | Philips Arena, Atlanta, GA | Gilbert Arenas |
| 2002 | NBA | Rookies 103, Sophomores, 97 | First Union Center, Philadelphia, PA | Jason Richardson |
| 2001 | NBA | Sophomores 121, Rookies, 113 | MCI Center, Washington, DC | Wally Szczerbiak |
| 2000 | NBA | Rookies 92, Sophomores, 83 | Oakland Arena, Oakland, CA | Elton Brand |
| 1998 | NBA | East 85, West, 80 | Madison Square Garden, New York, NY | Zydrunas Ilgauskas |
| 1997 | NBA | East 96, West, 91 | Gund Arena, Cleveland, OH | Allen Iverson |
| 1996 | NBA | East 94, West, 92 | Alamodome, San Antonio, TX | Damon Stoudamire |
| 1995 | NBA | White 83, Green, 79 | America West Arena, Phoenix, AZ | Eddie Jones |
| 1994 | NBA | Phenoms 74, Sensations, 68 | Target Center, Minneapolis, MN | Anfernee Hardaway |