46 Selections

2015-16
Paul George
2013-14
Paul George
Roy Hibbert
2012-13
Paul George
2011-12
Roy Hibbert
2008-09
Danny Granger
2006-07
Jermaine O'Neal
2005-06
Jermaine O'Neal
2004-05
Jermaine O'Neal
2002-03
Brad Miller
Jermaine O'Neal
2001-02
Jermaine O'Neal
1999-00
Dale Davis
Reggie Miller
1997-98
Reggie Miller
Rik Smits
1995-96
Reggie Miller
1994-95
Reggie Miller
1992-93
Detlef Schrempf
1989-90
Reggie Miller
1976-77
Don Buse
Billy Knight
1975-76
Don Buse
Billy Knight
1974-75
George McGinnis
1973-74
Mel Daniels
George McGinnis
1972-73
Mel Daniels
George McGinnis
1968-69
Mel Daniels
Bob Netolicky