I didn't realize how "close" according to the Keltner list he would be in terms of getting into the Hall of Fame.
All-Star selections shouldn't be a criteria in my opinion as they are simply popularity contests
All-NBA selections, although more worthy of consideration, are also somewhat popularity contests
There really isn't a "true" measure of who should be in versus out.

A great example of this will be Allen Iverson. He has got to be one of the most over-rated basketball players of ALL TIME. He will probably get into the Hall of Fame. My opinion of AI was confirmed when I read Wages of Wins by D Berri. I'd love to see the Keltner List done on AI (assuming that he as actually eligible today - he is not likely to affect his should/should not be in status by what he does in the future - in other words, one can easily form that opinion today).

Thanks - and keep up the great work

While KJ was selected to only three All-Star teams, he was selected to five All-NBA teams (four 2nd team selections and one 3rd team selection). There are seven other guards with exactly five All-NBA selections: Tiny Archibald, Clyde Drexler, Tim Hardaway, Bill Sharman, Sidney Moncrief, Mitch Richmond, and Isiah Thomas. Archibald, Drexler, Sharman, and Thomas are in the Hall of Fame; Moncrief and Richmond are not; and Hardaway is not yet eligible.

+-----------------+----------+---------+
| Player          | All-Star | All-NBA |
+-----------------+----------+---------+
| Derrick Coleman |        1 |       2 | 
| Phil Ford       |        0 |       1 | 
| Kevin Johnson   |        3 |       5 | 
| Drazen Petrovic |        0 |       1 | 
| John Stockton   |       10 |      11 | 
| Rod Strickland  |        0 |       1 | 
| Ben Wallace     |        4 |       5 | 
| Deron Williams  |        0 |       1 | 
+-----------------+----------+---------+

As you can see, KJ is the only player with a difference greater than one.